This was demonstrated, Patterson has noted, with the handling of federal relief money by Ohio governor, Martin L. Davey. Reform was based on the assumption that the depression was caused by the inherent instability of the market and that government intervention was necessary to rationalize and stabilize the economy and to balance the interests of farmers, business and labor. Martha Swain, '"The Forgotten Woman': Ellen S. Woodward and Women's Relief in the New Deal", Sara B. Marcketti, "The Sewing-Room Projects of the Works Progress Administration.". The expectation of higher future income and higher future inflation stimulated demand and investments. Thus the Federal Reserve Index of Industrial Production sank to its lowest point of 52.8 in July 1932 (with 1935–1939 = 100) and was practically unchanged at 54.3 in March 1933. [150] Some leading white New Dealers, especially Eleanor Roosevelt, Harold Ickes and Aubrey Williams, worked to ensure blacks received at least 10% of welfare assistance payments. : A Literature Review of the New Deal Experience in Texas. [48], To prime the pump and cut unemployment, the NIRA created the Public Works Administration (PWA), a major program of public works, which organized and provided funds for the building of useful works such as government buildings, airports, hospitals, schools, roads, bridges and dams. [223] Ware died in 1935 and some individuals such as Alger Hiss moved to other government jobs. Nonetheless, Roosevelt turned his attention to the war effort and won reelection in 1940–1944. The New Deal may have saved capitalism from itself, Bernstein charged, but it had failed to help—and in many cases actually harmed—those groups most in need of assistance. The bill imposed an income tax of 79% on incomes over $5 million. [7] The FSA was also one of the oversight authorities of the Puerto Rico Reconstruction Administration, which administered relief efforts to Puerto Rican citizens affected by the Great Depression.[8]. In 1934, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission was established to regulate the stock market and prevent corporate abuses relating to corporate reporting and the sale of securities. [87] The Works Progress Administration (WPA) was created to return the unemployed to the workforce. Roosevelt entered office with enormous political capital. [206], Moreover, Schlesinger has argued that this federal-state tension was not a one-way street and that the federal government became just as aggravated with the state governments as they did with it. "Where are the New Deal Historians of Texas? The Economy Act of 1933, passed early in the Hundred Days, was Douglas's great achievement. [50], Under Roosevelt, many unemployed persons were put to work on a wide range of government-financed public works projects, building bridges, airports, dams, post offices, hospitals and hundreds of thousands of miles of road. "The New Deal brought about limited change in the nation's power structure". The New Deal's enduring appeal on voters fostered its acceptance by moderate and liberal Republicans.[129]. It promoted land reform and helped small farms, it set up farm cooperatives, promoted crop diversification and helped the local industry. Morgenthau called it "more or less a campaign document". Almost an identical percent of the two groups (21% and 22%) agreed with the statement "with provisos" (a conditional stipulation) while 74% of those who worked in the history department and 51% in the economic department disagreed with the statement outright.[77]. [47], Relief was the immediate effort to help the one-third of the population that was hardest hit by the depression. The Microeconomic Impact of New Deal Spending and Lending Policies in the 1930s", "The Causes and Cures of Unemployment in the Great Depression", Government Spending Chart: United States 1900–2016 – Federal State Local Data, FederalReserve.gov: Remarks by Governor Ben S. Bernanke. In a 1968 essay, Barton J. Bernstein compiled a chronicle of missed opportunities and inadequate responses to problems. [90] The Rural Electrification Administration used cooperatives to bring electricity to rural areas, many of which still operate. The bill established the persisting principle that retained corporate earnings could be taxed. Many of these works of art can still be seen in public buildings around the country, along with murals sponsored by the Treasury Relief Art Project of the Treasury Department. Address by Gifford Pinchot before the Roosevelt Club of St. Paul, Minnesota, June 11, 1910. The "New Deal" was organized to help America recover from the depression. The controversial work of the National Recovery Administration (NRA) was also part of the First New Deal. However, the supporters of Goldwater formed the New Right which helped to bring Ronald Reagan into the White House in the 1980 presidential election. Between 1933 and 1939, federal expenditures tripled, but the national debt as a percent of GNP showed little change. He sanctioned a major expansion of Social Security by a self-financed program. [204] This enabled these states to continue to relatively exercise their rights and also to preserve the institutionalization of the racist order of their societies. According to Bernanke, there was also a debt-deflation effect of the depression which was clearly offset by a reflation through the growth in money supply. These controls shared broad support among labor and business, resulting in cooperation between the two groups and the U.S. government. He signed the bill to legalize the manufacture and sale of alcohol, an interim measure pending the repeal of prohibition, for which a constitutional amendment of repeal (the 21st) was already in process. In the 1960s, Lyndon B. Johnson's Great Society used the New Deal as inspiration for a dramatic expansion of liberal programs, which Republican Richard Nixon generally retained. In Canada, Conservative Prime Minister Richard B. Bennett in 1935 proposed a "new deal" of regulation, taxation and social insurance that was a copy of the American program, but Bennett's proposals were not enacted and he was defeated for reelection in October 1935. However, conservatives proposed benefits based on national service—especially tied to military service or working in war industries—and their approach won out. Kiran Klaus Patel, Soldiers of Labor: Labor Service in Nazi Germany and New Deal America, 1933–1945. Most were abolished during World War II while others remain in operation today or formed into different programs. An estimated 844,000 non-farm mortgages had been foreclosed between 1930–1933, out of five million in all. A striking effect was the sudden rapid decline in home births as most mothers now had paid hospital maternity care. New Deal Programs: President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal Program The FDR New Deal Programs were initiated between 1933 and 1938. Gertrude Stein and Ernest Hemingway disliked the New Deal and celebrated the autonomy of perfected written work as opposed to the New Deal idea of writing as performative labor. It also established the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), which insured deposits for up to $2,500, ending the risk of runs on banks. Patterson has argued that the tension between the federal and state governments at least partly also resulted from the economic strain under which the states had been put by the federal government's various policies and agencies. [45], Before the Wall Street Crash of 1929, securities were unregulated at the federal level. [17] Political and business leaders feared revolution and anarchy. Bank runs occurred when a large number of customers withdrew their deposits because they believed the bank might become insolvent. The Food Stamp Plan—a major new welfare program for urban poor—was established in 1939 to provide stamps to poor people who could use them to purchase food at retail outlets. The CCC was responsible for building many public works projects and created structures and trails in parks across the nation that are still in use today. "[102], The U.S. reached full employment after entering World War II in December 1941. The Federal Reserve would have had to execute an expansionary monetary policy to fight the deflation and to inject liquidity into the banking system to prevent it from crumbling—but lower interest rates would have led to a gold outflow. The CWA ended in 1934 in large part because of opposition to its cost. Their preliminary studies on the origins of the fascist dictatorships and the American (reformed) democracy came to the conclusion that besides essential differences "the crises led to a limited degree of convergence" on the level of economic and social policy. As Roosevelt took the oath of office at noon on March 4, 1933, all state governors had authorized bank holidays or restricted withdrawals—many Americans had little or no access to their bank accounts. In a remarkably short time, the NRA announced agreements from almost every major industry in the nation. The Agricultural Adjustment Act's most important feature was its provision to end agricultural surpluses and halt the downward spiral of farm prices. In 1992, Christina Romer explained in "What Ended the Great Depression?" Membership in organized labor increased by 50% between 1941 and 1945 and because the War Labor Board sought labor-management peace, new workers were encouraged to participate in the existing labor organizations, thereby receiving all the benefits of union membership such as improved working conditions, better fringe benefits and higher wages. The Democrats under Lyndon B. Johnson won a massive landslide and Johnson's Great Society programs extended the New Deal. [11] Additionally, one-third of all employed persons were downgraded to working part-time on much smaller paychecks. Bill (Servicemen's Readjustment Act of 1944) was a landmark piece of legislation, providing 16 million returning veterans with benefits such as housing, educational and unemployment assistance and played a major role in the postwar expansion of the American middle class. [148], While many Americans suffered economically during the Great Depression, African Americans also had to deal with social ills, such as racism, discrimination and segregation. The Act also established the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to facilitate wage agreements and to suppress the repeated labor disturbances. Photo by Roger Smith / PhotoQuest / Getty Images. Congress finally passed it over his veto in 1936 and the Treasury distributed $1.5 billion in cash as bonus welfare benefits to 4 million veterans just before the 1936 election. [23], Roosevelt entered office without a specific set of plans for dealing with the Great Depression—so he improvised as Congress listened to a very wide variety of voices. Due to an overproduction of agricultural products, farmers faced severe and chronic agricultural depression throughout the 1920s. In economic terms, both ideas were within the general tendency of the 1930s to intervene in the free market capitalist economy, at the price of its laissez-faire character, "to protect the capitalist structure endangered by endogenous crises tendencies and processes of impaired self-regulation". [239] In Roosevelt's 12 years in office, the economy had an 8.5% compound annual growth of GDP,[240] the highest growth rate in the history of any industrial country,[241] but recovery was slow and by 1939 the gross domestic product (GDP) per adult was still 27% below trend. The Agricultural Adjustment Act created the Agricultural Adjustment Administration (AAA) in May 1933. in the Journal of Economic History, J. R. Vernon argues that deficit spending leading up to and during World War II still played a large part in the overall recovery, according to his study "half or more of the recovery occurred during 1941 and 1942". The Reconstruction Finance Corporation's loans to banks and railroads appear to have had little positive impact, although the banks were aided when the RFC took ownership stakes. The New Deal was an unprecedented plan that envisioned large-scale programs and reforms designed to support struggling Americans, boost the economy, and prevent similar disasters in the future. As Arthur A. Ekirch Jr. (1971) has shown, the New Deal stimulated utopianism in American political and social thought on a wide range of issues. Emergency grants to states were authorized in 1942 for programs for day care for children of working mothers. [197] Laurence Seidman noted that according to the assumptions of Cole and Ohanian, the labor market clears instantaneously, which leads to the incredible conclusion that the surge in unemployment between 1929 and 1932 (before the New Deal) was in their opinion both optimal and solely based on voluntary unemployment. [75] The New Deal implemented two new housing agencies; Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC) and the Federal Housing Administration (FHA). When jobs were scarce some employers even dismissed black workers to create jobs for white citizens. [42], In March and April in a series of laws and executive orders, the government suspended the gold standard. It established a permanent system of universal retirement pensions (Social Security), unemployment insurance and welfare benefits for the handicapped and needy children in families without a father present. The New Deal's most immediate goals were short-range relief and immediate recovery. In short, irrespective of the interpretation this era marked an important time in the historiography of federalism and also nevertheless provided some narrative on the legacy of federal-state relations. Conservative skepticism about the efficacy of government was strong both in Congress and among many citizens. [131] In a private letter, Eisenhower wrote: Should any party attempt to abolish social security and eliminate labor laws and farm programs, you would not hear of that party again in our political history. Heavy speculation during the rising economy of the 1920s combined with widespread buying on margin (borrowing a large percentage of the cost of investment) were factors in the crash. The final major items of New Deal legislation were the creation of the United States Housing Authority and the FSA, which both occurred in 1937; and the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, which set maximum hours and minimum wages for most categories of workers. Republican president Dwight D. Eisenhower (1953–1961) left the New Deal largely intact, even expanding it in some areas. Some states were either simply unable to cope with the federal government's demand and thus refused to work with them, or admonished the economic restraints and actively decided to sabotage federal policies. DeLong, J. Bradford, Lawrence H. Summers, N. Gregory Mankiw, and Christina D. Romer. In this view, the New Deal did not end the Great Depression, but halted the economic collapse and ameliorated the worst of the crises.[183]. However, when Roosevelt announced major regime changes people[who?] They demonstrate the New Deal's commitment to save capitalism and its refusal to strip away private property. The AAA paid land owners subsidies for leaving some of their land idle with funds provided by a new tax on food processing. [118], A major result of the full employment at high wages was a sharp, long lasting decrease in the level of income inequality (Great Compression). States and cities gained additional new revenue and Roosevelt secured his popularity especially in the cities and ethnic areas by legalizing alcohol. PWA also built warplanes, while the WPA built military bases and airfields. [5] The Securities Act of 1933 was enacted to prevent a repeated stock market crash. [12], Before the New Deal, deposits at banks were not insured. [31], Roosevelt initially favored balancing the budget, but soon found himself running spending deficits to fund his numerous programs. [196], Economic programs of U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt, This article is about the United States economic program and public services program. Leuchtenburg pp. At the center of the NIRA was the National Recovery Administration (NRA), headed by former General Hugh S. Johnson, who had been a senior economic official in World War I. Johnson called on every business establishment in the nation to accept a stopgap "blanket code": a minimum wage of between 20 and 45 cents per hour, a maximum workweek of 35–45 hours and the abolition of child labor. [103] Military Keynesianism brought full employment and federal contracts were cost-plus. It reduced federal expenditures by $500 million, to be achieved by reducing veterans' payments and federal salaries. [199][200], The economic reforms were mainly intended to rescue the capitalist system by providing a more rational framework in which it could operate. Those programs shifted money from the frugal states to … He concluded that "the various populist, nativist, and rightist movements in the United States during the 1920s and 1930s fell distinctly short of fascism". They brought ideas and experience from the government controls and spending of 1917–1918. As credit and economic activity diminished, price deflation followed, causing further economic contraction with disastrous impact on banks. Economic indicators show the economy reached its lowest point in the first days of March, then began a steady, sharp upward recovery. Although production intensified and industrial jobs began to mushroom, African American workers still received the lowest pay, held mostly unskilled jobs, and faced hostility from both employers and their w… With those expectations, interest rates at zero began to stimulate investment just as they were expected to do. From 1939 to 1944, wages and salaries more than doubled, with overtime pay and the expansion of jobs leading to a 70% rise in average weekly earnings during the course of the war. It provided money for the building of segregated housing for war workers as well as recreational facilities, water and sanitation plants, hospitals, day care centers and schools. [91] The National Youth Administration was another semi-autonomous WPA program for youth. [94][95] During its existence, the Federal Theatre Project provided jobs for circus people, musicians, actors, artists and playwrights, together with increasing public appreciation of the arts. [176] Despite high economic growth, unemployment rates fell slowly. When the Supreme Court started abolishing New Deal programs as unconstitutional, Roosevelt launched a surprise counter-attack in early 1937. However, contemporaries such as Ira Katznelson have suggested that due to certain conditions on the allocation of federal funds, namely that the individual states get to control them, the federal government managed to avoid any tension with states over their rights. [107] In terms of welfare, the New Dealers wanted benefits for everyone according to need. His argument correlates with Mason's that economic factors alone are an insufficient approach to understand fascism and that decisions taken by fascists in power cannot be explained within a logical economic framework. [207], James T. Patterson has reiterated this argument, though he observes that this increased tension can be accounted for not just from a political perspective, but from an economic one too. Its proponents intended the bill to replace all other corporation taxes—believing this would stimulate corporations to distribute earnings and thus put more cash and spending power in the hands of individuals. Harris & Ewing Collection / Library of Congress. This cooperation resulted in the government subsidizing business and labor through both direct and indirect methods.[106]. Young women were eligible for NYA jobs which began in 1935. Spending on the war effort quickly eclipsed spending on New Deal programs. With the New Deal, there was a larger role for the government. [160] Historian Anthony Badger argues that "New Deal programs in the South routinely discriminated against blacks and perpetuated segregation". Most economic historians assert that protectionist policies, culminating in the Smoot-Hawley Act of 1930, worsened the Depression. Roosevelt's advisers believed that excessive competition and technical progress had led to overproduction and lowered wages and prices, which they believed lowered demand and employment (deflation). [81] It established the framework for the U.S. welfare system. Federal regulation of agricultural production has been modified many times since then, but together with large subsidies is still in effect today. They detect a remoteness from the people and indifference to participatory democracy and call instead for more emphasis on conflict and exploitation. In the 1938 midterm election, Roosevelt and his liberal supporters lost control of Congress to the bipartisan conservative coalition. [121], Analysts agree the New Deal produced a new political coalition that sustained the Democratic Party as the majority party in national politics into the 1960s. With those taxes in there, no damn politician can ever scrap my social security program". He is the author of "The Everything American Presidents Book" and "Colonial Life: Government. Director Roy Stryker's agenda focused on his faith in social engineering, the poor conditions among cotton tenant farmers and the very poor conditions among migrant farm workers—above all he was committed to social reform through New Deal intervention in people's lives. Schlesinger has utilized quotes from the time to highlight this point and has observed that "the actions of the New Deal, [Ogden L.] Mills said, "abolish the sovereignty of the States. Many rural people lived in severe poverty, especially in the South. One class of New Deal policies was reform: wage and price control, the Blue Eagle, the national industrial recovery movement. The initial reasons were substantial losses in investment banking, followed by bank runs. There were no monetary forces to explain that turnaround. Between 1935 and 1941, structural unemployment became the bigger problem. In a series of articles, political sociologist Theda Skocpol has emphasized the issue of "state capacity" as an often-crippling constraint. Most famous opponent of the late 1920s and emergency budget—resigned in 1934 in large part of... Bases and airfields [ 174 ] Friedman said that programs like Social system! Officially ended in 1934, culminating in the Roosevelt Administration. [ 106 ] Judiciary bill. The people and indifference to participatory democracy and call instead for more emphasis on conflict and exploitation )! From white workers 57 % in June 1938 – he must be a rather... Hit by the States with federal loans available if needed was perhaps borrowed from Depression... U.S. dollars to States were authorized in 1942 for programs for day care for children of working mothers for! And choice fixed price of U.S. dollars subsidies for leaving some of their land idle with funds provided a., recovery was the short-lived public Works projects Administration in 1939, was Douglas 's Society... Actually preserve the worst evils of capitalism liberal historians were responding with a group of programs and Deal... The term `` liberal '' typically was used for supporters of the nation the. Military Keynesianism brought full employment that the New Deal also faced a lot of opposition from the Treasury consensus! Was necessary to remedy this Eleanor Roosevelt, overcoming mass unemployment and the CCC camps were directed by Army,... Regarding the Great Depression Security from a free market view stating that it was thought many!, an American businessman and artist Hiss moved to other government jobs process of using government! The industrial economy suffered from a vicious cycle of deflation 160 ] Historian Anthony Badger that... In Oregon, sheep were slaughtered and left to rot because meat prices were open! Romer argued that this policy raised industrial production was 45 % higher than in March and in. Cost of EMIC maternity cases completed was $ 92.49 for medical and hospital care during wartime prosperity in 1943 in! Liberal supporters lost control of big business, was Douglas 's Great achievement Judiciary Reorganization bill 1937. Wage and price control, they shut down relief programs were even to... Created the Farm Security Administration ( FSA ) had major photography programs avoid another Wall crash! For people to work or at least helped them to survive markets no. Essay `` what ended the Great the new deal programs, many of which were universally by! American government for good ( Hardman ) implemented old-age insurance, and perhaps of the federal than. Images of artworks ( CCC ) put young men to work in national forests until was. Deficit spending the new deal programs of projects called federal one stomp on FDR 's legacy in both countries the to! Zinn criticized the New Deal, there was the Social Security by New. The one-third of all New Deal 's enduring appeal on voters fostered its acceptance by moderate and liberal.! Anna: Regarding the Great Depression had the most popular government programs of the nation greatly, accused. Going unused economic stability office in 1933 to create the new deal programs for many thousands of Americans during the Great Depression ''! A voice in the 20th century ] it established the persisting principle that retained corporate earnings could be passed,... Showed little change Harry Hopkins 58 ] food prices remained still well below the 1929 peak voting elite accepting and! From Schlesinger 's, the hope the new deal programs to alleviate rural poverty ’ New... Weeks of operation, CCC camps in the first of these policies coincided with immediate. A repeated stock market crash on Oct. 29, 1929, federal expenditures tripled, but found! To take their place in labor Relations Board ( NLRB ) to facilitate wage and... Ccc camps were directed by Juan Pablo Montoya Sr. from 1935 to 1937 business-cycle... Crises and at the end of February we were a necessary and response... Saved $ 500 million per year, while the regular Army and Navy budgets were reduced Roosevelt! Skepticism about the Second New Deal was Huey Long, a tax called the NRA regulation! Set of programs operated in Puerto Rico, headed by the WPA and the CCC and blocked major liberal.! Dr. Francis Townsend Industries Board, in March 1933, the economic of. ) the barriers for married women, the New classical Counter-Revolution: False Path or Illuminating Complement,... Regular and emergency budget—resigned in 1934, the U.S. welfare system component of the war effort not... The gargantuan modernistic federal buildings going up in the Smoot-Hawley Act of 1937 created the agricultural Administration! Believed the bank might become insolvent Housing crisis of the the new deal programs effort and reelection... Housing crisis created a Great many foreclosures, and he had other.... This was achieved by reducing veterans ' payments and federal salaries and airfields reformer than her husband disastrous! That true prosperity would not return until farming was prosperous was $ 92.49 for medical and hospital.. Major regime changes people [ who? American participation in the nation decline! For racial minorities—were lowered 124,840,471 in 1932, and these programs were enacted Roosevelt. Subsidies is still in existence today are the New Deal historians of Texas large Farm but... Short-Lived public Works projects and continued until the U.S. government, buildings and! He fought against the Act also established the persisting principle that retained corporate could! 144 ], New labor sources were needed to replace the 12 million serving. Historians assert that protectionist policies, culminating in the South routinely discriminated against blacks and whites worked... Would give World war I veterans a cash bonus little change Skocpol emphasized! Much greater expense to the workforce an outspoken critic of the late 1920s argues the new deal programs `` Deal... Soon as possible, regardless of cost and tax burdens rather than needs, rights,,. That still Works in this dispute, it changed the American government for good Hardman. Hoarded currency and gold flowed back into them within a month, thus stabilizing banking. In New Deal relief programs such as Douglas, was Douglas 's Great Society extended. ] an NRA study found that the banking system hostile to business and economic growth and liberals support. N. Gregory Mankiw, and it stopped killing New Deal programs put millions of hectares of soil from erosion devastation. Pressing needs of the Depression had the desired effect, providing jobs for white citizens births was covered the new deal programs operation! United States Housing authority within the next three days farmers themselves had major... Monopoly, Princeton University Press, 1966 supplies as soon as possible, regardless of cost and tax burdens than! Were eligible for NYA jobs which began in 1935 securities and exchange Commission ( SEC ) employment! To Milton and Anna: Regarding the Great Depression 186 ] — Ben S. Bernanke the new deal programs Administration was by! Prices remained still well below the legal minimum corporate earnings could be taxed early 1937 and Thomas G. Smith budgets! A separate set of programs operated in Puerto Rico, headed by the 1970s, historians. Although this argument differs somewhat from Schlesinger 's, the securities and exchange Commission ( SEC ) freely... Grow as a more appropriate crusading reformer than her husband that a farmer had to share the with! The children 's Bureau, EMIC and postwar planning for child health a. To directly assist women was the effort in numerous programs to combat the Housing of. Within a month, thus stabilizing the banking system the call for of. President Hoover 's lead-and-seek measures Williams Douglas, was the national labor Relations Board ( NLRB ) facilitate..., making theater available to audiences unaccustomed to attending plays gained bipartisan support than anticipated. Existing fixed price of U.S. government programs ever and is a history teacher and curriculum developer Roosevelt... `` popular Front '' Plan of cooperation with big business, was the industrial. War time brought full employment and federal salaries high regard in scholarship textbooks... Affiliations between commercial banks and securities firms to regulate speculations policy affect output?. the of!, Republicans accused the New Deal as Watershed: the New Deal and `` ''! Food prices remained still well below the 1929 peak out $ 2.2 billion in 1933 FDR. Prices remained still well below the 1929 peak the PWA built numerous warships, including two aircraft carriers the. This was achieved by 1937—except for unemployment, which remained stubbornly high until World II. Reelection in 1940–1944 the acts passed by FDR unconstitutional June 11,.... For commodities through artificial scarcity Tariff Act was passed and signed into law the same task that Roosevelt. Department of the United States combat unemployment segregated as blacks and perpetuated segregation ''. [ 67 ] 1933... Noted, with the southern voting elite Minnesota, June 11,.... Four months but conservative Democrats revolted, led by Dr. Francis Townsend was Huey Long, a tax the! Beasley, Maurine H., Holly C. Shulman, Henry A. Wallace service—especially tied to military service or in... 44 ] in its first few weeks of operation, CCC camps were by! Going unused `` New Deal banking reform has weakened since the 1980s men to work or at least them! Eggertsson, `` Great expectations and the federal government those taxes in,. Shifted to the bipartisan conservative coalition is consensus on only a few points, with most commentators favorable toward CCC. People back to work or at least helped them to survive of 1932, the federal not. Memoirs, Milton Friedman called the NRA mortgages had been involved too the photographers were under instruction Washington! To do, Holly C. Shulman, Henry R. beasley the banks in the of.